What You’ll Learn from Tabletop Vibes’ Entertaining and Insightful Gameplay Review
If you’re curious about the experience of playing Colonize: The New World, there’s no better introduction than the in-depth, unscripted, and humorous review by the team at
Tabletop Vibes.
In this 12-minute video, the crew offers a first-hand look at what it’s like to explore, expand, and rebel against the crown in this rich 4X board game currently in development.
Rather than a dry rules explanation, this review is filled with reactions, gameplay stories, and commentary on what makes the game shine—and where it hits players hardest.
Viewers get a front-row seat to the team’s experience playing as competing colonial empires, making high-stakes decisions, and dealing with unpredictable royal decrees, combat outcomes, and player betrayals.
Highlights from the Review
- Initial Impressions: The game is described as “huge” and “ambitious” right out of the gate. The reviewers are visibly impressed by the scale and complexity of the game’s systems.
- Liberty vs. Tyranny: One of the most entertaining moments in the video is when one player declares independence—only to be immediately punished by overwhelming royal forces. This leads to a discussion of the risk-reward balance of breaking free from the king’s rule.
- Founding Fathers & Strategy Layers: The Tabletop Vibes team breaks down how cards like Ben Franklin and Paul Revere create permanent bonuses, but also escalate tensions with the king. These moments show how strategy evolves mid-game.
- Diplomacy & Player Negotiation: The group spends time talking about the flexible treaty system, allowing for open-ended player deals that can lead to betrayal, alliance, or bribery. They loved the unpredictability and social gameplay this created.
- Native Tribes & Resource Mechanics: The reviewers explore the two major paths—trading peacefully or raiding tribes for treasure. Each player chose a different route, which created unique tensions and ethical choices.
- Combat & Dice Mechanics: They explain how dice are used in battles and how terrain and modifiers add depth to skirmishes. It’s tactical, but also accessible, making it easy for newer players to jump in without being overwhelmed.
- The Sea Beast Encounter: A hilarious segment covers a mysterious sea monster that appears mid-game. It’s a wildcard mechanic that offers a massive gold reward—but only if you survive. Their reactions are worth watching alone.
What the Review Reveals About the Game’s Feel
This review isn’t just about explaining what each mechanic does—it’s about capturing what it feels like to play. The team highlights the emotional rollercoaster of building a powerful colony, only to risk it all for freedom.
They talk about moments of regret, triumph, betrayal, and laughter. By the end of the video, you don’t just understand the game better—you understand whether this game’s tone and pace are for you.
If you’ve ever played games like Scythe, Twilight Imperium, or Civilization: A New Dawn, you’ll find familiar territory here—but with a twist.
Colonize: The New World adds a deeply thematic layer of revolution, debt, diplomacy, and monarchic control that makes every decision feel weighty and personal.
Watch the Full Review
Click above to watch the full review from Tabletop Vibes and experience the highs, lows, and sea beasts of Colonize: The New World for yourself.
More from Tabletop Vibes
Tabletop Vibes continues to grow a reputation for fun, insightful reviews that focus on the player experience—not just the box text.
If you enjoy playthroughs, reviews, and candid reactions from passionate gamers, be sure to
subscribe to their YouTube channel.